You’re familiar with Bloody Mary, the Hookman, and the Killer in the Backseat. For centuries, urban legends have been an enormous part of our storytelling history. Because they stir something primal in people. They evoke our greatest fears. And our paranoia. Or even our laughter. But not all stories are as famous as other. There are still some juicy legends that may surprise you. So here are 25 urban legends you never heard of (until now).