5. Alyssa Edwards vs. Coco Montrese, Season 5
When two arch-rivals go up against each other in a lip sync for your life, you know they are going to leave it all on the dancefloor. That is just what Alyssa and Coco do when they perform to Paula Abdul’s ‘Cold Hearted’. Coco points to her lips while nailing every word of Paula’s speedy delivery, while Alyssa does a twirl-jump-splits for the gods. This is a grudge match and we are all the better for the animosity. Alyssa goes home, but they are both winners baby.