Moon Shoes
Average original price: $37.52
Potential earnings: $200
Moon Shoes were designed to make us feel like we’re walking on the moon, hence the name. They were a bit more expensive than the other toys but definitely worth the price. Parents paid $37.52 for their kids to have some fun. But in reality, these shoes were more awkward and clumsy than practical, but children still had fun with them. These days, you can get $200 for the Moon Shoes on eBay.