6. The Fiend
“The Fiend” Bray Wyatt sports one of the creepiest masks in wrestling history. He debuted in 2009 along with his brother and made a name for himself in the wrestling world. As The Fiend, he became a one-time SmackDown Tag Team Champion and a WWE Champion. The mask probably got too uncomfortable for him to wear because in 2012, he decided to take it off and reveal his new persona, Axel Mulligan. He then started wearing a hockey mask, much like horror movie villain Jason. Nowadays, he is back to being Bray Wyatt, but toned his darkness down a lot.