Lizzy Caplan Then
If you’re wired a certain way, you always had crushes on the goth girls in high school. If that sounds like you, then you probably weren’t as interested when you saw “Mean Girls” in Lindsay Lohan or any of the Plastics as you were in Janis. She was played by Lizzy Caplan, who at that point was known mainly for showing up in a handful of “Freaks and Geeks” episodes a few years earlier.