The 25 Creepiest ‘Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark’ Illustrations That Gave Every ’90s Kid Nightmares

19. A New Horse

scary stories to tell in the dark illustrations
IMAGE BY: HarperCollins

It isn’t that this horse looks more like a donkey with a spinal issue. It’s that this horse is wearing a woman’s high heel on one of its back feet, while the opposite foot is exactly that. A human foot. 

Scroll to Top