Nick Foles
Quarterback Nick Foles has had one of the strangest careers in the NFL, and you could argue that two of his seasons qualify for one-season wonder status in completely different ways. First was his sophomore season in 2013, when he became the Eagles’ starter and compiled an amazing 27-2 touchdown-to-interception ratio. His next two years as a starter were terrible, including one with more interceptions than touchdowns, but he got another chance with the Eagles due to Carson Wentz’s injury right before the playoffs in 2018. Foles put together an incredible run culminating in a Super Bowl victory where he had three passing TDs and one receiving TD, good for game MVP honors.