Steve Bedrosian, 1987 NL Cy Young
A reliever needs to be untouchable to claim Cy Young honors, and Bedrosian wasn’t that in 1987. He pitched to a solid 2.83 ERA and posted a majors-leading 40 saves. You’d need a second hand to count out the more deserving candidates in the NL that year, and they split the votes to leave the door open for the Phillies closer.