Tom Glavine, 1998 NL Cy Young
Glavine had a Cy Young caliber season in 1998, but at least two guys had better years— and one of them was on his own team. Greg Maddux posted a better ERA and WHIP over more innings, as did Kevin Brown, who also had 100 more strikeouts than Glavine did. Brown probably had his vote split by Padres teammate Trevor Hoffman.