Any Gold Glove won by Derek Jeter
Jeter won five Gold Gloves — in 2004, 2005, 2006, 2009, and 2010 — all after turning 30. But he posted a positive dWAR (according to Baseball Reference) in just one of those seasons. Jeter has a pair of memorable highlights to his name, and he definitely made fielding a grounder in the hole between second and third look cool, but he just was never a great fielder, particularly as he aged.