9. Robert Mathis
The Colts scooped the defensive end with the 138th pick of the 2003 NFL Draft, and the move would pay off in a huge way. Mathis spent his entire career with the Colts, recording an NFL record 54 forced fumbles and a franchise record 123 sacks. The tandem he formed with fellow defensive end Dwight Freeney helped lead Peyton Manning’s 2006 Colts to victory in Super Bowl XLI.